Question 1

What does it mean to be physically dependent on a medication or other substance?

Accepted Answer

Physical dependence means the body has adapted to a drug being present. Taken away too quickly, the body reacts with withdrawal symptoms, and over time the same dose may do less than it once did, which is called tolerance. This happens with many medications, blood pressure drugs and antidepressants among them, as well as benzodiazepines, and it happens to people who take them exactly as directed. It is a predictable response of the nervous system, not a character flaw and not a choice.

Question 2

How is dependence different from addiction?

Accepted Answer

Addiction is a pattern of behavior: compulsive use, loss of control, and continuing despite harm. Dependence is a state of the body. The two words were blurred together for decades, partly because a diagnostic manual once chose "dependence" as the gentler term for addiction, and the confusion has cost patients dearly. A person who takes a medication as prescribed, on schedule, and has never once misused it can still be profoundly dependent on it. Dependence is not addiction.

Question 3

Can dependence exist without addiction?

Accepted Answer

Yes, and for most people taking a benzodiazepine as prescribed, that is exactly the situation. Many of the people I see have taken the same dose, exactly as directed, for years and often for decades, without once deviating from the prescription. A person who follows the prescriber's instructions to the letter shows none of the behavior that defines addiction, so what they have is dependence and only dependence. The Food and Drug Administration says so in plain words: a patient may be physically dependent on a drug without having an addiction to it, and tolerance, dependence and withdrawal are expected consequences of long-term treatment with certain drugs. When that distinction is missed, a patient asking for help with withdrawal symptoms can be labeled as drug seeking and refused, which is how people end up stopping abruptly.

Question 4

Why are benzodiazepines different from other medications that cause dependence?

Accepted Answer

Many medications cause physical dependence and nothing more. Antidepressants, antipsychotics, some blood pressure drugs and corticosteroids all produce withdrawal when stopped too fast, yet people do not crave them or take extra to feel an effect. Benzodiazepines are different in one respect. They can be intoxicating and they can be misused, which is why rehab programs like to call them alcohol in a pill. The comparison does not hold. Abuse potential is a property of a drug. Addiction is a condition in a person, defined by compulsive use, loss of control and continuing despite harm. A drug that some people misuse does not make the person taking it as prescribed addicted, and most people on a benzodiazepine never misuse it. Their dependence is the same kind of dependence a person has on a blood pressure pill, and it deserves the same response: a careful taper, not a label.

Question 5

What is deprescribing?

Accepted Answer

Deprescribing is the planned, supervised reduction of a medication that a person no longer needs or that is doing more harm than good, carried out at a pace the body can tolerate. For benzodiazepines that means a slow taper over months, with reductions that get smaller as the dose gets lower, and a plan that follows the patient's symptoms rather than a calendar. It is the opposite of a prescription simply not being renewed. On this show, deprescribing also covers antidepressants, antipsychotics, gabapentinoids and sleep medications, because the same principles apply.

Question 6

Why do benzodiazepine-dependent patients need deprescribing and not rehab?

Accepted Answer

Rehab was built for addiction. It treats compulsive use with abstinence, group work and a quick detox, and for the right patient it can save a life. For a person who is physically dependent on a prescribed benzodiazepine, that model does harm. Detox units tend to stop the drug over days, which is when seizures and the most frightening withdrawal reactions occur, and which may raise the risk of symptoms that last for months or years. Professor C. Heather Ashton wrote that addiction detoxification units are not appropriate for prescribed benzodiazepine users, and the Maudsley Deprescribing Guidelines say the same. What these patients need is time, a slow taper, and a doctor who stays with them.

Question 7

What is BIND?

Accepted Answer

BIND stands for benzodiazepine-induced neurological dysfunction. It is the term now used for the constellation of symptoms that can occur during and after benzodiazepine use and tapering, including while a person is still taking the same daily dose. The symptoms can be neurological, cognitive and physical, and BIND can mimic other neurological conditions closely enough to be mistaken for one. Professor Ashton described protracted withdrawal in the same patients decades earlier. The point of the name is that this is an injury caused by the drug, not a return of the original anxiety and not a sign of weakness. I wrote a longer explanation in What BIND Is.

Question 8

How does a lack of informed consent and a rushed office visit lead to long-term dependence, and for some, BIND?

Accepted Answer

Informed consent means being told the risks before the first prescription: that tolerance and physical dependence can develop within weeks, that stopping suddenly can be dangerous, and that there needs to be a plan for coming off. Many patients were never told any of that. I understand how it happens, because many doctors were taught to prescribe this way: a short visit, a diagnosis, a prescription, a refill, and no conversation about how or when it would end. When the medication stopped working, the usual answer was a higher dose, and when a patient said they felt worse, it was read as the anxiety coming back. The Food and Drug Administration found the same pattern when it strengthened the benzodiazepine boxed warning in 2020. Years pass that way, and some people arrive at BIND without ever having done anything wrong.

Question 9

What happened to the addiction episodes?

Accepted Answer

They are all still here. This show began in 2018 as an addiction podcast, and the episodes about the opioid epidemic, buprenorphine, alcohol, harm reduction and recovery remain in the Episodes archive, along with the articles from those years on the blog. I stand by that work. It is where I learned that forcing a fast taper on anyone, from any drug, fails, and that lesson is the heart of what the show does now. If you are here because of a benzodiazepine or another psychiatric medication, start with the Benzodiazepines and Psychiatric Drugs series, then read why a slow taper works and a fast one fails and what the Ashton Manual says. This page and this podcast are for educational purposes only. Nothing here is medical advice, and nothing here creates a doctor-patient relationship. Physical dependence on a prescribed medication is not addiction.

Adam Bisaga, M.D.: Promising New Research On Treatments for Opioid Use Disorder

Abe Malkin MD, MBA: Prioritizing Your Health With Concierge Medical Services

Is There Help For Parents Of Addicts And Support For Families Of Addicts?

Samara Ibanez: TSM Coaching For Success In Reducing Or Quitting Alcohol

GET IN TOUCH

| THE SHOW

| CONTACT